Justin Bieber's Coachella set felt made for the online era in the best way
Justin Bieber did not spend his Coachella headlining set pretending the past was behind him. Instead, he opened a laptop, pulled up YouTube, and sang directly to it.
Midway through his 90-minute set on Saturday, the Day Two headliner began streaming old clips of himself performing snippets of songs like "Baby," "Favorite Girl," "Never Say Never," and "Beauty and a Beat," duetting with the floppy-haired, younger version of himself that first made him famous. "I feel like we gotta take you guys on a bit of a journey... How far back do you guys go?" Bieber asked the crowd. "Do you guys really go back, though? Like for real, for real?"
SEE ALSO:The internet made BTS. 'Arirang' asks what comes next.
The most striking moment came when the 32-year-old pulled up the grainy 2007 YouTube video of 12-year-old Justin singing "So Sick" by Ne-Yo, one of the clips that helped get him discovered in the first place. That particular video was uploaded nearly 20 years ago, back when YouTube still felt like a place where anyone could stumble across a talented kid singing in a local competition, not an endless scroll optimized by algorithms, and before the internet regularly produced its own stars.
It was a deeply meta moment: Bieber was singing along with YouTube while YouTube streamed his performance live to millions of viewers worldwide. He'd occasionally talk to the audience watching from home, looking into the camera like a friend FaceTiming from his living room, not from the Main Stage at Coachella.
But it also felt bigger than a nostalgia play. Bieber is one of the last true pop superstars whose mythology is inseparable from an earlier version of the internet, one where a kid uploading covers from his bedroom could still plausibly become one of the biggest artists on the planet. The internet still produces stars, but they are different now — more fragmented, more niche, more algorithmically siloed. Platforms produce creators, influencers, and a rotating cast of micro-celebrities, but few Justin Biebers.

That is what made the performance feel unexpectedly emotional. Bieber was not just revisiting old clips; he was revisiting the child the internet turned into Justin Bieber. Many former child stars look back at old footage, and it feels a bit silly or even sad. Here, though, Bieber seemed genuinely at peace with it. He smiled at the videos. He harmonized with his younger self, treating him less like a brand asset and more like someone worth meeting again.
That intimacy was reinforced by the set's understated nature. Most Coachella headliners are expected to deliver a giant spectacle: elaborate stage design, pyrotechnics, dancers, and some sort of viral visual moment engineered for social media. Bieber, dressed in a hoodie, mostly gave the crowd a laptop, a camera feed, a few guests (the Kid LAROI, Dijon, Tems, Wizkid, Mk.gee), and his voice.
For some viewers, that made the set feel underwhelming, especially in a festival slot that usually expects excess — Day One headliner Sabrina Carpenter rolled out five Dior costume changes and complex Hollywood-inspired sets on the same stage. There is also probably a fair conversation to be had about whether a female pop star delivering Bieber's style of sparse, emotionally inward performance would have been criticized more harshly for doing too little. But part of what made his set so fascinating was its refusal to play by those expectations at all.
Instead of building some futuristic world around himself, he turned the stage into something closer to a bedroom computer circa 2009: YouTube tabs open, old videos surfacing one after another. His voice has arguably never sounded better, and the lack of elaborate staging made the set feel more confident, not less. Bieber didn't need spectacle. The emotional reveal was the point.
Even the stranger, more meme-heavy moments of the set fit into that framework. Bieber recited along to his own "standing on business" paparazzi rant, pulled up unrelated viral clips like "Deez Nuts," and turned the stage into something that looked less like a traditional concert and more like a browser window with too many tabs open. Call it his version of "gay guy music video night" — an intimate, almost devotional evening spent pulling up pop hits, deep cuts, and formative internet ephemera for 100,000 of his closest friends in the Indio desert.
That is what celebrity looks like in 2026: less like a polished narrative and more like a living archive that anyone can revisit anytime, where each version of you exists fossilized in digital amber. Old interviews, paparazzi clips, memes, viral moments, performances, scandals, and forgotten uploads all live side by side online, waiting to resurface. What Bieber did at Coachella felt like walking through that archive on his own terms, choosing which versions of himself to revisit, which memories to reclaim.
In that sense, the set was not really about nostalgia at all. It was about what it means to live long enough online to have multiple versions of yourself floating around the internet at once. At Coachella, Bieber did something stranger and more moving than a greatest hits set: He logged into his own internet history, smiling at the screen as though he was finally making peace with the kid inside it.
Topics Music Social Media YouTube Celebrities


felt compelled to write about this, so here it goes. Last night, I stayed up late to watch Justin Bieber perform at Coachella. His set didn't start until 11:30 p.m. and wrapped up around 1 a.m. I wasn't sure what to expect, though I had high hopes after seeing a clip from his recent small concert in West Hollywood.
ReplyDeleteFrom the moment he started, I was pleasantly surprised. Justin appeared genuinely happy and carefree, fully enjoying the moment. At 32, he seemed more at ease than in his younger years. His performance on a simple stage brought to mind other artists I've admired. It reminded me of when I saw Luis Miguel and Cheyenne years ago. Luis Miguel, performing with the Nelson Riddle Orchestra in the 90s, didn't need flashy effects; his presence and voice were enough. Similarly, Cheyenne's later performances focused more on him rather than the spectacle.
Justin's performance last night had a similar vibe. Despite some criticisms I've read about him only singing snippets of songs, I found his performance profoundly moving. It was like watching a man who has come full circle. Considering his tumultuous past—struggles with drugs, alcohol, manipulation, and constant media scrutiny—I can't even imagine what he's been through.
A unique moment was when he played videos of his younger self on screen while he sang. It was the first time I've seen an artist literally turn around, face their past, and perform with it. He delivered exactly what we wanted: not the cute boy or the handsome young man, but Justin, the singer who has captivated us for years.
It seems that becoming a father has profoundly changed him. I hope this marks a new chapter in his life. Watching him perform was a joy, and I hope you enjoyed it as well.
I agree. I am so proud of Justin. I just pray God will put his loving arms around he and Hailey. Hailey is a remarkable person for believing in Justine when nobody else did!
DeleteThis portion was 20 minutes out of 90 lol it was a lot of fun and the crowd loved it. Most of the hate comes from news outlets who want a story to run with and from people who weren’t there. It was a blast in my opinion and the YouTube portion fit his personality.
ReplyDeleteGood.
ReplyDeleteWelcome to Hell
ReplyDeleteHe has been through a lot and I was proud of his courage, tonight he was fire
ReplyDeleteIt was pure art, purely him and no gimmicks. It was raw, intimate, real. The simplicity really focused in on him, the lighting, the stage, the giant screens and camera work. I thought it was so edgy in a minimalistic way yet futuristic way. Ufo-like. His act evoked pure emotions. The laptop segment was genius because it showed him being down to earth and grounded, no need for grandeure gestures. If people don't see that then it's really their loss.
ReplyDeleteAlso give this guy a break! He has been beat down so badly and is now healing. I think this clearly shows his mental state which is calm and clear and people who get it just get it. You can't compare him to other stages.
Say what you will but it was a pretty iconic set. If this would’ve been a standalone Bieber show at a big venue, I would’ve been let down, but as a festival when other artist are putting immense shows all day, I thought it was pretty cool, minimal but kind of intimate and almost interactive.
ReplyDeleteGood for him, he can do whatever he wants. They did whatever they wanted with him. He owes nothing to anyone, and yet, he keeps sharing. Go away haters
ReplyDeleteMy wife is a fan and her and her friends loved it, they thought it was amazing seeing the old videos and him singing with his younger self. I think he did a show for fans and it worked as intended.
ReplyDeleteTo me it just seemed like he wanted connection and humanisation in his performance and I don’t fault him for that. He’s been idolised and probably under a lot of pressure to perform most of his adult life. His fans probably loved it.
ReplyDeletethe crowd seemed to like it
ReplyDeleteSounds pretty damn authentic to me. I’m glad he’s being himself instead of catering to everyone else. The man deserves to be happy.
ReplyDeletePeople want a show not a therapy session
ReplyDeleteSounds like a cool show and I’m not a bieb fan
ReplyDeleteHaters gonna hate
It’s so on brand for the kid that got famous from YouTube to just chill with his audience while watching YouTube videos. I kind of love it tbh
ReplyDeleteSFGate is such a garbage online website with the pay-walls. Gauging the comments, his performance sounds pretty rad and wholesom (especially in 2026).
ReplyDeleteHuh. Honestly sounds kinda cool. (And I’m not a Bieber fan.)
ReplyDeletePeople had a lot of fun and that’s all that matters
ReplyDeleteI actually really enjoyed it.
ReplyDeleteThis sounds hilarious.
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed it
ReplyDeleteI think he just wanted to walk down the memory lane. I get the theme. But he could have implemented this whole 'nostalgic' concept in a creative way (if he wanted to).. But at the end of the day ig this is what he wanted, but I can't even imagine the hate if this was done by some other headliner at Coachella.
ReplyDeletei deeply fuck with this
ReplyDeleteThe YouTube break is literally his childhood on YouTube. Him singing to his older songs was like an appreciation but also grieving over his past and future.
ReplyDeleteAnd I think older songs are not licensed so he looped hole by technically not singing the whole song and doing a quick throwback.
To tack onto this, I heard on a podcast (maybe Jessica Benson show?) that the YouTube thing may have been because he doesn't own the masters or something to his early songs. That's why he performed his more recent release, then sang along to YouTube clips of his older stuff. Possibly a protest of some kind, possibly a statement on someone else making money off of his work? I was only half paying attention, Reddit sleuths could possibly clear it up
DeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
DeleteHow many daily posts have to be about this?
ReplyDeleteIt really only needed one post for it to be discussed
Literally couldn’t care less and yet I’ve had to read about it 10000 times already. So whatever it was, I’d say it was effective!
ReplyDeleteHe got paid $10 million for this by the way
ReplyDeleteLotta people in the comments not understanding the why behind it. Just do a little research people
ReplyDelete
ReplyDeleteLook, I'm all for him "healing" or however you call it and fans are pointing out that he can't perform his songs because he sold his rights so... WHY GO TO A MUSIC FESTIVAL? Taylor swift couldn't perform her songs when she was still battling with her label but did she perform in that award show like she just woke up? Nope.
This performance could have been a youtube video for an anniversary. Heck, it could have been a tiktok reel,
Is it because he doesn’t own the music anymore? A way to not pay royalties ?
ReplyDeleteI loved the show
ReplyDeleteit was actually really cool
ReplyDeleteArtistic brilliance.
ReplyDeleteI think many of the complaints about his performance are rooted in the opinion that women in the industry would never be allowed to get away with such a performance without MASSIVE ridicule.
ReplyDeleteDang Bieber what you doin?
ReplyDeleteImagine paying to go see a guy scrolling through YouTube. Generational trolling 🤣🤣
ReplyDeleteHe showed the Double Rainbow guy video
ReplyDeleteI’m not a fan but I thought it fit where he’s at as an artist at the moment. First half hour was slow but everything after that was interesting from an outsiders perspective.
ReplyDeleteI only watched on YouTube but that was the healthiest and happiest I’ve ever seen him look.
ReplyDeleteI loved it! It was the first time my husband and I have ever watched him am really enjoyed his performance and music!
ReplyDeleteListen, there’s few artists I’d say I’d be grateful for anything from them and JB is one of them. I cannot imagine what he went through at such a young age, the fact that he’s not more lost in Hollywood is a blessing.
ReplyDeleteWasn't weird it was just lazy. He's been half assing his entire life for years. He cries constantly about everything but does nothing about it.
ReplyDeleteI thought it was pretty cool.
ReplyDeleteCould also have to do that he might not have rights to play the songs as it was rumored that he sold his masters to them a year ago. So he would have to pay money to actually perform them vs using YouTube as a loop hole to just have a sing along.
ReplyDeleteThe youtube premium joke and showing youtube up on the screen felt very branded
ReplyDeleteGood I'm proud of him. He isn't a monkey in a circus. He's a person.
ReplyDeleteIt was just One big ad for YouTube premium that people paid for.
ReplyDeletedidnt Frank Ocean kind of do this like 2 years ago?
ReplyDeleteFor all this guy has been through, his audience wants “authentic” Justin. And this is his/their definition of it.
ReplyDeleteI’m sure the cover band at the pub down the street had a better set.
ReplyDeleteHow long before he's in videos with Brittany doing knife dances?
ReplyDeleteso funny to hear people talk shit when they clearly just don't get it
ReplyDeleteIt's called a back track. It's no different. Alternatively, why is it acceptable for Ed Sheeran to use his guitar loop pedal, but this isnt? He hant sang "Baby" live since 2012. This was his first concert since 2022.
ReplyDeleteThis performance is actually intelligent. Paying homage to his career. Jb doing karaoke via youtube and enjoying it just like he did when he was "discovered ". Most importantly, he's happy doing it.
YouTube gave that guy some cash. His video views are gonna be even bigger now.
ReplyDeleteI think he sounded great live all things considered. The set was nice and the fans seemed to be engaged.
ReplyDeletehe sold the rights to all of his old stuff. creative way to still perform some of it at least
ReplyDeleteIf Gaga had done this, she'd be ripped apart. Held to completely different standard.
ReplyDeleteI heard he did the YouTube thing so that the new owners of his old music can’t profit off it.
ReplyDeleteRemember, he sold his music catalog in 2023 I think.
So that means he needs permission from the new rights owners to play his old songs.
However, since he brought them up on YouTube and basically “covered” them…..he doesn’t have to ask permission, and they’re not able to profit from his performance.
Cool little loophole, if true.
I dont normally care, follow pop headlines or comment- but I thought his choice to do this instead of an over the top set suited his current mood/rage against the machine.
ReplyDeleteAlso paid homage to yt for how he was discovered
The crowd loved every minute of it. You can watch the stream. Entertainment writers are a timid bunch it seems.
ReplyDeleteEvery Bieber fan I know loved it. They started following him by watching YouTube and singing along. Him recreating that was great for them.
ReplyDeleteIs this supposed to be like his ‘stripped down’ grammy appearance?
ReplyDeleteLet’s be honest, what would he have to do to make a generation of freakishly obsessed people not like him? He could throw up on stage and call it art.
ReplyDeleteNah not really shut up.
ReplyDeleteHe swerved the audience
ReplyDeleteI think it was pretty cool actually.
ReplyDeleteHe got 10M to go on stage and run YT videos lmao
ReplyDeleteDo you only read headlines or what? He still did over an hour set
Deletehe started out on youtube. he performed songs we haven't heard him sing since he was a child. he was up there smiling and having fun, harmonizing with his younger voice. as a fan it made me sooo happy it brought me to tears. this man has been through so much, hated on profusely as a child yet everybody was screaming his old songs. it was beautiful.
ReplyDeleteI thought it was cool and a nice full-circle moment for his career. His tunes are ok, I’m not a hardcore fan, but it seemed a propos to me.
ReplyDeletePossibly related, but I sometimes find bands filling in for fully or mostly DAW production in pop acts to be lackluster, so this performance avoided that pitfall and had the cool bonus of him dueting with his younger self.
This guy has ALWAYS been such a drama queen. Stop contributing to him. There’s plenty of better artists out there.
ReplyDeleteNot in regards to Justin, but there's something fascinating about how men (in the western world) can't really be pop anymore. Or rather why isn't there any?
ReplyDeleteWe know (straight) men will never like pop guys. So pop exists because of women. Yet there's no pop men now, so I can only imagine women don't want pop men anymore and only accept pop women. Just an observation.
Now im not a justice beaver fan, nor did I see his set, but it sounds like a pretty chill and intimate affair.
ReplyDeleteNot everything has to be fireworks and auto tune.
justins Coachella set was awesome I loved it
ReplyDeleteIt’s really weird he played at a festival at all much less with Nine inch nails.
ReplyDeleteDude life is a spiraling mess, his substance abuse is worrying
ReplyDeleteIt was an incredible performance. I'm not a Bieber fan and he was so, so good. All these articles are essentially ragebait for people who are perpetually offended.
ReplyDeleteI watched the stream VOD and timed it because of all the media coverage, the YouTube stuff was literally 21 minutes out of a 90 minute set. Any outlet treating it as if he did the laptop the entire time is clearly just doing it for fake outrage and clicks.
ReplyDeleteThe exact opposite of the expectations put on him as a polished child pop star. Good for him
ReplyDeleteJ Biebz can do what he wants. I don't listen to his music besides like one or two songs that I don't remember the name of. But shit as far as I understand he was just singing between putting on songs and showing people his old clips and talking about them? I don't see nothing wrong with that. His fans are in love with him too so they probably liked that shit. They got a little chillin experience w the Biebz and got to hear his thoughts and feel like they're kicking it w them. Theres a pretty big group of people that sit at home and watch streamers too who talk and watch YouTube videos n shit like that. So seems pretty similar to me just instead of on a screen he's right in front of you! #freeJBiebz
ReplyDeleteI liked the laptop part. Idk it felt weirdly intimate despite the crowd.. like we were all just collectively hanging out with him, the real justin, for a minute.
ReplyDeleteI was there and thought it was cool, I heard the only way he could play the throwbacks was like that on youtube as he had sold the rights a few years ago. The crowd loved it everyone knew every single word! Seemed like he was having fun too
ReplyDeleteNobody has to like it but it wasn’t “weird.” He literally just got up there in a hoodie and shorts and sang live. Maybe the you tube part came off weird but his fans understood it. I felt it was a tad boring at points but not weird or wrong.
ReplyDeleteJustin Bieber was discovered via YouTube. This is a nod to his beginning
ReplyDeleteDylan would have pulled this move if YouTube would have existed in his day
ReplyDeleteWas there. Loved the set.
ReplyDeleteA singer at one of the biggest music festivals in the World. No musicians on stage. Sigh.
ReplyDeleteThere were multiple other singers and musicians that guested with him including the guitarist mk.gee who played an amazing closer.
DeleteBut no one actually playing ‘the music’? No guitarist, no bassist, o drummer etc that’s what makes me sad.
DeleteI thought he sounded great but unfortunately this world is drowning in negativity and I'm not even a huge fan. He did plenty of songs without the computer and it was kinda cool that he took us through his older songs. Justin sang all the full songs without a backing track, he did an acoustic set and he brought out two artist's which were both great. If you ask me the crowds are the problem with Coachella because they are so disconnected from the show and worried about holding their phones up for validation.
ReplyDeleteThis sounds like a better performance than a dj just playing music from his MacBook and acting like he is the singer
ReplyDeleteI like it. It’s subversive. Kind of pointing out how ridiculous Coachella has gotten. With each festival getting more and more expensive, food prices sky high, cheap facilities and increasing prices if you want access to decent facilities. The whole thing is a scam. Him going up there with his laptop and a mic is giving people there what they deserve, instead of what they think they deserve. They let this thing that was supposed to be about music and musicians into this big money grabbing, influencer infested, distillation of where we are as today as a country. Where the music and talent don’t matter, just the glam and shiny bright distraction. He stripped it back down to what it’s supposed to be about. Bieber can sing, he doesn’t need anything else but a microphone and a stage.
ReplyDeleteSabrina fans are trying to turn this into a gender issue, but frankly Sabrina doesn’t have the songs or talent to just go up there, naked with nothing but a microphone and spotlight and keep that audience engaged and captivated. Not saying she isn’t talented but right now she needed to put on a show because without it nobody would be talking about her.
He’s insufferable
ReplyDeleteIt would be a lot more passable if he were still hot
DeleteIf he grew some hair, he'd easily look pretty good.
DeleteIDK how people listen to that.
ReplyDeleteA lot of this backlash feels pushed by media with a narrative to bring him down.
ReplyDeleteIt’s art, you wouldn’t understand.
ReplyDeleteReddit needs to find something to complain about
ReplyDeleteI’ll take what he did 100 times over something like Sabrina Carpenter’s
ReplyDeleteThis was his artPOP. No I won’t elaborate.
ReplyDeleteDISAGREE. it was iconic. It was so him. It was exactly what it needed and was to be.
ReplyDeleteBig brain move ... where other artists spent time,effort and alot of money for their setup. The boy went woth no effort and banked all of his 10 million paycheck
ReplyDeleteSure. But Coachella is really weird.
ReplyDeleteI thought the laptop thing was cool, it felt personal, like hanging out with a friend.
ReplyDeleteHe made his money. He doesn’t give a shit about his fans.
ReplyDeleteI thought it was lazy but incredibly creative. It would’ve been happy with that performance
ReplyDeleteI think this is Brown as fuck, just not planned very well.
ReplyDeleteFuck it, make every concert a low budget, intimate, spontaneous show where you can just bullshit with your fans.
The only people that said it was bad were people at home too broke and envious they didnt get to see it
ReplyDeleteI like weird Biebs better than normy Biebs ngl
ReplyDeleteIt was not. You are just basic
ReplyDeleteLoved the set. My gf grew up a huge Bieber fan and I’ve grown an appreciation for his sound. The set felt like a love letter to his fanbase. Personal, intimate, uncontrived, honest. I was thoroughly impressed by what I saw.
ReplyDeletePeople who “didn’t get it” just sound really shallow and uncultured. He is an amazing artist and one who doesn’t need the pomp and circumstance.
ReplyDeleteNever been a fan. But I do know his story and it’s terrifying. He’s been abused and exploited his whole youth. Let him have it. Also it’s not that big of a deal. The people that were there looked happy and like they enjoyed it
ReplyDeletethey are on a lot of things
DeleteJpegmafia changed the game fr
ReplyDeleteCreative choice
ReplyDeleteHe’s turning into kanye
ReplyDeleteIt really fucking was.
ReplyDeleteI saw a post that said “he got to perform with every era of himself.” That’s really special when you think about it.
ReplyDeleteThe difference between his set and Sabrina’s was crazy.
ReplyDeleteNot familiar with Bieb’s at all, but I thought it was fine.
ReplyDeleteWith that said, I went to 7 coachellas and trust me, Saturday nights headliner should be a banger. Don’t care if it’s pop, rock, edm, hip hop. Whatever it is, people want to dance their asses off and rage.
Justin’s set was the complete opposite of that. When you get back to camp or your hotel, we were always buzzing from excitement and had a hard time falling asleep. Some Saturday headliners I saw were: Muse, arcade fire, Radiohead, jack white, Guns N’ Roses.
Seems like everyone who was there loved it
ReplyDeleteDude’s tryna pull a Vince Staples
ReplyDeleteInternet being mad at the sky once again…
ReplyDeleteI see nothing wrong with this let the man live he’s just having a good time
ReplyDeleteNext year he should send a random guy in his place to poorly sing his hits and do a Q&A session.
ReplyDeletei think it was a very real, authentic, intimate and unique set. Very original idea!
ReplyDeleteFeel like I’m going insane and a lot of people are missing the point. A minute of research would tell you that his newest album is as subdued and minimal as he’s ever been. His Grammy performance was intimate and minimal, just like this Coachella performance. This felt like your homie coming over and y’all just kick it and play YouTube videos and sing songs together. I personally loved it, it felt like something he himself wanted to do which he deserves after having a career where he was doing the complete opposite every step of the way.
ReplyDeleteI thought it was pretty cool. Love the Biebs
ReplyDeleteI’m not a huge fan by any stretch, but I thought it was brilliant. It was definitely different and it was bold. Whoever’s idea it was, I can imagine the meeting. “You wanna what??? Have him scroll through his computer and sing to YouTube videos?” And that was the brilliance of it. It was totally for those grown up Beliebers. It was a big walk through memory lane. The way they most likely discovered him. Through YouTube videos of early performances that they watched over and over when they were kids. He made it feel very intimate. At FUCKING Coachella. No fireworks, no huge dance numbers, no dJ’s waving their hands senselessly. No, costume changes. No lip syncing. It went against everything we’ve ever seen. I promise you, it will be considered one of the most bold performances in ‘chella history. Tupac hologram be dammed.
ReplyDeletepreach!. it was brilliant
DeleteWill go down as the first of the "return to analog" performances
ReplyDeleteI liked his Coachella performance he had a smile on his face that looked genuine and I was happy for him.
ReplyDeletethis, for sure!
DeleteNot even really a jb fan but I got mad respect for him doing that and kinda trolling
ReplyDeleteSeems like he cutting the cost off all the production staff. More money in his pocket and less shows. Equals more time at home with family.
ReplyDeletei feel bad for his fans who are making up excuses that he was "healing his inner child" during this set. no bro hes tweaking and this is all he could do ..... white men literally get away with the bare minimum
ReplyDeleteEven if it is like that for him, it sucks how, for example Gaga and Beyonce are always expected to put on a remarkable show but he just.. Does this. In the middle of all the performances with actual effort
Delete"This could have been an email."
ReplyDelete...anyways Nine Inch Noise knocked it outta the park! Easley top 10 sets in festival history!
Weird because it was specifically without voice correction AI lol all the real music heads will recognize him actually singing.
ReplyDeleteI don't think this would be getting as much hate if he performed the hits in full instead of just a minute of each
ReplyDeleteSo fucking lame lol
ReplyDeleteIf recommend for everyone to watch the livestream for themselves. All these headlines are just such a far stretched from the truth. It’s a great seat & im far from the beliber.
ReplyDeleteVocals on point, though.
ReplyDeleteSounds like he did it for himself. Good.
ReplyDeleteHe’s so rich he just doesn’t gaf anymore. I feel him on that. It’s similar when you get older.
ReplyDeleteAll the girls I went to school w posted stories talking about they were crying tears of joy so I think it went fine
ReplyDeleteOk am I crazy I thought his school project eras tour was kinda cool and made a giant venue somehow intimate? I’m not really a fan and just watched it on YouTube but I thought it would be gratifying as a fan. I’ve seen artists that don’t give nearly as much time to the songs people love that got them there. And he was discovered on YouTube!! Idk it was cool imo
ReplyDeleteETA: maybe it’s not clocking to you
This would have been perfect for some pop out or lower tier cheap concert . I d be pissed if I paid my whole rent to se that lol
ReplyDeleteNgl as someone who doesn’t give af about Justin Bieber, I thought it was a very touching and great performance from him…I loved it
ReplyDeleteDude has a pretty wild neurological disorder give him a break and be happy he is still out preforming.
ReplyDeleteIsn’t that the point. It’s Coachella, this controversy brings clicks and generates views and revenue. Nobody would be talking about a “normal” JB performance.
ReplyDeleteNot wierd. Its more that justin just dont care and the audience dont care. Its just about hits, click and clout.
ReplyDeleteHe also started playing old embarassing videos of his, and I think that is hilarious
ReplyDeleteNot even a JB fan and the livestream was fun. However in person that would’ve sucked shit and I would’ve been pissed if I paid for that.
ReplyDeleteDude was chewed up and spit out and abused by the industry. He got 10 mil out of a bunch rich dickheads to just chill with his audience and do whatever he wanted. Good for him.
ReplyDeleteI’m not a JB fan by any means but I don’t really get the backlash to this or his Grammy’s performance. Seems like he’s just done trying to be the flashy popstar everyone wants him to be and instead is doing these stripped back raw performances. I can respect that
ReplyDelete100%. Felt like a hang out / little more intimate. And honestly, he has so many hits, I'd rather him go through and perform a minute of all his crowd favorites and get twice as many songs performed, than a full set of new songs not as popular or something.
DeleteI agree!
DeleteThis could have been a Zoom call.
ReplyDeleteSeems to be a ton of articles saying this was terrible and a ton of people that were there saying they loved it.
ReplyDeleteEveryone I know that watched it loved it tho...
ReplyDeleteI actually like how rebellious this is.
ReplyDeleteSo lazy it’s rebellious
DeleteI watched some clips and recall his Oscars performance. It seems like his artistic expression. I think it's not being will received. My guess is He doesn't care.
ReplyDeleteHonestly I’m all for it. It sounds like an intimate experience rather than a typical over production one. Weird performances always become more memorable and later praised with time
ReplyDeleteKinda punk rock, imo
ReplyDeleteThis is an absolutely shit take on what happened
ReplyDeleteIt was awesome.. I liked it
ReplyDeleteHe must pay for Ad-free YouTube.
ReplyDeleteI get that everyone expected bells and whistles, but… that’s never been his style, has it? Why would he change that and not give a true performance, in his style?
ReplyDeleteI’m not a massive fan, and I was defs caught off guard by his show, but after watching a few clips, I get it. He’s not known for feathers and pyro (nothing wrong with that!), this wasn’t the time to start just because of what others have done.
“I can’t believe Justin Bieber’s set sucked!”
ReplyDeleteI feel like him singing lower to contrast his younger self and a much simpler/more raw production represents more of where he’s at right now. He also did a “stripped” down performance at the Grammys recently, nearly undressed with simple looping and vocals. Feels more raw and authentic than his overly produced past stuff, I think it’s kinda cool. I haven’t been able to see the complete Coachella set, just nearly all of the songs he did in clips. I could see how people in attendance may have wanted a larger production.
ReplyDeleteStrange how fame can make some so, well, … strange.
ReplyDeleteumm, I liked it. it was VERY justin. and the pics of baby Justin seemed to be evoking a lot of emotion. ive seen Lil Wayne concerts where he DANCES thru clips of Wayne songs. he barely sings at all during that time. its nostalgia. People wanna hear their favorite songs and this was a sweet way to do it.
ReplyDeleteI thought it was cool ngl.
ReplyDelete“Good thing he has youtube premium…”
ReplyDeleteKaty Perry
bro, when I heard and read about this I thought it was a lie... what a time to be alive
DeleteIm shocked so many people feel this way. I thought it looked great! It was funny, hype, and chill all in one. A friend of mine was at his show last night and she was obsessed with it. I think people are being way too harsh.
ReplyDeleteI honestly thought the laptop section was great. It may have seemed under-produced but it was him showcasing his earlier stuff in an almost full circle way. The reality is, he is a 30 year old man now - he isn’t a teen anymore and has really developed a lot musically. He was never going to get up there and dance like Beyonce or T Swift as many people probably expected. His vocals were good.
ReplyDeleteDo people forget how he started and the role youtube played?
ReplyDeleteSeemed like an obvious statement to me... and simultaneously gave the crowd what they wanted without consuming all the time.
Lmao the comments were spamming where is Justin during the Strokes performance only to get this serves them right
ReplyDeleteTaste is so subjective. The crowd seemed very into it. I loved it, exactly for the intimate feeling. He just nailed every minute of that performance.
ReplyDeleteWho goes to Coachella for Bieber… ?
ReplyDeleteI am not a Justin Bieber fan of any capacity but I thought the set was great. Using the livestream to choose songs and showing old youtube videos really brought me a feeling of nostalgia and made me appreciate his songs in a way I didn't before. Not sure why this article is hating. Sorry you didn't enjoy it buddy but this article just sounds sad and desperate for attention.
ReplyDeleteI wasn’t there, obviously I can barely afford to watch a Bieber tribute artist lol, but this actually sounds cute, sweet and refreshing
ReplyDeleteWe know he knows how to do a big production - we didn’t know he could be cute a low key too
My hot take anyway
I think bieber just needs company.
ReplyDeleteDidn't some rapper do the same or something similar? Frank Ocean maybe? Have to hold these artists to some kid. Of standard
ReplyDeleteHis wife married a celebrity. She needs him to perform.
ReplyDeletecoachella sounds like it sucks. Even the old version. People who attend this shit are weird.
ReplyDelete"people who go to concerts are weird" - The_Poop_Shooter, 2026
DeleteRich people who go into the middle of the desert with air conditioned campers to dress like madmax extras and listen to pre-recorded sets by corporately curated musicians are weird.
DeleteEvery big event nowadays is like that, at Coachella it's extremely hot, lot of waiting and you most likely aren't going to be able to enjoy the performance'to the fullest due to other factors.
DeleteWhat we witnessed Saturday night has a name in the corporate world: quiet quitting. Technically you are present but you are minimally functional and produce as little as possible while collecting the check.
ReplyDeleteThis performance was nothing but a display of his contempt for his fans and the industry. He thinks fame took everything from him - his childhood, his privacy and his mental health.
This wasn't a comeback, it was a payback for everything he perceives his fame, fans and the industry have taken from him.
So he delivers the absolute bare minimum performance in the history of his career and collected the $10M, and is basically darying anyone to complain. Because he knows his stupid vapid fans will defend it, call it "art" and buy weekend 2 tickets. Because he knows he will sell tickets regardless what he delivers so he delivers absolutely nothing and gets paid.
I wondered about that. Looking at the clips I thought, "he got paid 10 million dollars for this." But, I guess they were ok with it? Someone had to approve his set and mics and setup.
DeleteComment has been removed
Delete