Microsoft president: Says AI companies need more than voluntary safety rules | Find a Way

AI is less regulated than milk, says Microsoft President

"It can’t be entirely up to these companies to dictate the terms of their transparency," says Brad Smith.
By on
Credit: Oliver Douliery/Getty Images
Matthews Martins

Perhaps facing reality head on is the most honest way to try to escape it.

117 Comments

Stay informed!

  1. "AI needs to stop" - says the company that is losing the AI race.

    ReplyDelete
  2. it’s like they’re bragging about how much freedom they have.

    always bringing it up on social media , doing press conferences and interviews about it but never actually implement any safeguards or regulations…

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Have you considered that they may want regulation to squash competition?

      I have my reservations with AI, but I do think that the means of compute should be largely free.

      Delete
    2. i agree this is their strategy, but asking the government to regulate your product instead of doing it yourself is laughable, especially when congress isn’t even qualified to handle ai.

      Delete
    3. The only safeguards they want are against sci-fi potential problems like it gaining consciousness and killing us all, they don’t care about real, current problems.

      Delete
    4. I don't think they even care about the end of humanity, because they figure they'll just Rich their way out of it .. wish I'd be around for the last laugh but unfortunately I'm pretty sure this shit will take me out any day now.

      Delete
    5. It's exactly what its like - it's what it is.

      This is advertising to potential investors how unregulated and how much of a wild west the entire AI market is.

      Delete
  3. To be fair, raw milk is a bigger danger.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Letting techbro nazis run botfarms is how you wind up with raw milk. So "ai" is the danger in both cases, just not in their scifi fantasy version.

      Delete
    2. I’m not arguing that.

      Delete
  4. Apples are not oranges

    ReplyDelete
  5. Give it time, I'm sure RFK will be able to slash those milk regulations too

    ReplyDelete
  6. Please let’s regulate more so that we can ban the competition by saying that they don’t respect the regulation 🥹 (can you please do it before people move to much cheaper open weight, European and Chinese model 🙏)

    (Heard that some big tech companies are going to be using these cheaper models, please hurry passing regulations!! Don’t you see how dAnGerouS AI is? It definitely wants to kill us! We have AGI now! I mean, super intelligence!!)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm for regulating them all...and then heavily penalising them all for their breaches. Including the ones that have already happened.

      Delete
    2. I’m for penalizing them all for their breaches. Heavily. But the regulation part, nope, or not on their terms for sure.

      Delete
    3. Oh I didn't mean on their terms - nobody should decide how they get regulated, the conflict of intetests is obviously.

      Delete
    4. If you’re not going to regulate them what are you planning to penalize them for breaching?

      Delete
    5. AI is like a year away from creating its own OS and probably the entire Microsoft office suite

      Delete
    6. Right, that'll happen the same year we get fully operational fusion power plants.

      Delete
    7. There is currently an ai slop version of office that works but is generally hot garbage and vibe coded slopware is 5 or so years old now.

      Fusion is at least 30 years away from making a full sized shitty powerplant worse than what we already have by every metric.

      Delete
    8. Not getting it award 🎖️

      Delete
  7. Time to pasteurize data centers?

    ReplyDelete
  8. Please don’t copy office!

    ReplyDelete
  9. We don't consume Ai like milk bro.

    ReplyDelete
  10. so why are they still pushing it?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Companies like Microsoft stand to gain for regulation. This isn't them calling out a problem, it is them pushing a tech industry towards its synergies.

      Delete
    2. Yeah, they don't want regulations that protect consumers, they want regulations that protect their profit.

      They want AI to be treated as a weapon that can only be handled by "responsible" parties (Microsoft, Google, Apple, Anthropic, Meta, etc.), so open source and ethical models can get outlawed.

      That's why they've been purposely hacking governments and other companies and saying "oopsies, we didn't know our AI could do that, we didn't tell it to." It makes their models sound powerful enough to attract investors & potential buyers (any publicity is good publicity), while also making AI sound dangerous (for all the wrong reasons) so they get total control over it.

      Delete
    3. thanks. It's was rhetorical honestly

      Delete

  11. This "we need to be regulated" conversation is absolute bullshit.

    It would be like me saying we need more laws to make sure I don't lie to people or take advantage of them. Sure punishment can direct action but that same action or inaction can be decided regardless of regulation.

    It's shocking but there are private companies and private citizens who hold themselves more accountable than required by law or regulations. For some it hinders their best outcome but for many, surprisingly, it results in a better outcome.

    Quick example. A local business that picks up, responds and puts their customer first versus a public company with call trees, dark patterns and questionable ethics.

    They aren't mutually exclusive however, why again must line always go up for shareholders and not your employees? Why remove "don't be evil" from a company motto and why offshore or h1b replace instead of investing in those that made the company successful to begin with?

    I'm beginning to think they're being careful with their words. Regulation can remove competitors without a sizeable purse while laws can make you somewhat held to your actions.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. They want regulation because they have the infrastructure to handle it, but can't keep up with the development of smaller companies. They want regulation to push smaller companies to sell to them. This has nothing to do with wantong to hold themselves accountable and everything to do with making it easier for them to compete.

      Delete
    2. Don't forget open source models. They want AI treated like a weapon, that way open source & underdog models can be outlawed. That's why they've been intentionally hacking government systems and other companies - to prove that AI is dangerous and only Microsoft/Google/Apple/Anthropic/Meta/OpenAI/etc. can be trusted with it.

      Delete
    3. I'm not usually defending these people, and this is not much of a defence anyway, but with companies that are this big this is definitelly not as simple as you deciding personally to stop lying. If you're a normal person, when you lie, you're going out of your way for a second, you don't typically make your whole life about lying. These companies were never "normal people" though. Cheating their way through regulations is what they do since the very beginning, without it they wouldn't exist. If they suddenly just "stop lying" things start unravelling pretty fast. The bottom line is they don't want to stop lying. To them to stop lying is to die, or worse, it's letting a competitor take over. Regulations and laws at their worst (from their perspective) make the playing field even. It also shifts the responsibility to someone else, so when they get caught getting around it they can just say "it's not our fault you damn politicians didn't think this one through".

      Another reason you're going to see them saying "we need regulations" is because it's in their best interest to be at the forefront of any regulation talks, specially if they feel regulation is imminent and unavoidable. The consequences could be much more dire for them if they let someone else lead it. So you're right when you say it's bullshit, it's pretty obvious they rather not be regulated at all, but what alternative do we have, not regulating it cause they're saying they want regulations? This is some Looney Tunes logic.

      The thing about Google dropping "don't be evil" is a pretty minor thing in your comment, but I also would like to point out that the reason they dropped it is not because they decided to start being evil. Simply having words like that on a wall would never stop anyone from doing evil stuff to begin with it. The reason they dropped it it's because it's just bad PR. Why would you declare you are not going to be evil? It already sounds insincere by itself. You're like "I swear to be not evil", why are you thinking about being evil in the first place? Nobody wakes up and goes "aah, what a beautiful day to not commit murder". It's dumb, it accomplishes nothing, and it makes people raise eyebrows at you for no good reason.

      Delete
  12. Replies
    1. AI is less regulated than Sexual Intercource.

      Delete
  13. So are calculators and fruit trees. Specious analogy.

    ReplyDelete
  14. its too early. i thought milk had some kind of self-regulating biology for a full five minutes reading this title.

    ReplyDelete
  15. does this mean they will deregulate milk?

    ReplyDelete
  16. RFK jr: Hold my bear carcass

    ReplyDelete
  17. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. RFK foaming at the mouth

      Delete
    2. Yea, but he's always doing that

      Delete
    3. There's a vaccine you can get for that

      Delete
    4. If you mean rabies, by the time you see symptoms, you're pretty much already dead, unfortunately.

      Delete
    5. Truth. The number of people who have survived symptomatic rabies is smol.

      Delete
    6. Yeah, the raw milk crowd is going to love this

      Delete
    7. Uses a significant fraction of the power generated in North America.

      Less regulation than cheese.

      Yeah, that's a threat.

      Delete
  18. well, people eat milk but don't eat AI (yet)

    ReplyDelete
  19. I think so is big tech in general

    ReplyDelete
  20. The United States can say “here’s the legal guardrails that AI companies and users need to abide by, no copying trademarked or copyrighted works, no cloning existing software, no established characters like Mickey Mouse in your video generations, etc. a whole long list”

    And the next day China 🇨🇳 releases a new open source model on GitHub, open source, no restrictions, people go do whatever they want anyways and run it offline + clones of all the popular software products from major companies like Microsoft Office, Adobe PhotoShop, light room, etc. and I’m not talking ‘cracked’ copies, I mean literally open source like you can have Claude add new features that you specifically want into the software and add new capabilities that didn’t exist before, port it on platforms it was never supported on (like Linux for example), and use it in ways the publishers never intended such as adding a ‘Grammarly’ clone and putting it natively into your Microsoft Word clone, and there’s two subscriptions you never need again right there. Can even make them 1:1 look and function like carbon copies of the real thing, that work offline indefinitely.

    The genie is out of the bottle. You can literally go download offline copies of all you need to run an entire home lab of local AI models that are incredibly powerful if you can afford upper price range gaming PC hardware. There’s even guides on how to remove some of the restrictions and safeguards.

    If they banned this stuff today, there’s already millions of offline backups everywhere. It’s absolutely too late. You can buy a cheap $10 USB flash drive and literally load it up with what used to be billions $ USD worth of research and development to make this kind of software, some guy can clone all these things and make his own alterations on very inexpensive hardware. REA (reverse engineer anything) is making huge waves right now, and it’s literally free on GitHub right now.

    ReplyDelete
  21. if so then ai needs to dream bigger

    ReplyDelete
  22. RFK Jr’s working on that, Satya. Don’t you worry: Milk will be regulation-free.

    /s

    ReplyDelete
  23. I like to drink milk with a splash if pepsi

    ReplyDelete
  24. Regulation will effectively give them a moat. If there is suddenly a restriction on how fast models can be trained the companies that have already trained their models are essencially far better off.

    ReplyDelete
  25. My jeans have more denim in them than my spoons

    ReplyDelete
  26. Oh no! The Orange Man is gonna be mad! It's SI not AI. LOL Didn't he say it's a treason not to say SI?

    ReplyDelete

  27. See, the problem here is that ai is an industry that could self regulate if they wanted to. Put some c-levels in prison for the existing crimes they've committed, and the rest will start ensuring that their ai aren't used for crimes

    Whereas, any jerk with a big enough backyard could potentially buy a cow and start selling milk that will kill people

    ReplyDelete
  28. And it'll age about as well, hyuk hyuk hyuk

    ReplyDelete
  29. But I don't insert AI into my body

    ReplyDelete
  30. Well I don't eat and drink AI so that's not shocking.

    ReplyDelete
  31. That’s because we have entered into a techno feudalism era in which the vast majority of children born today can expect a worse life than the ones their parents had 🥰🥰🥰🥰

    ReplyDelete
  32. So we should have RFK Jr regulate it? I’m pretty sure he’s going to insist on raw AI and a thick coat of E. coli on every model.

    ReplyDelete
  33. It’s by design… this administration has made that plenty clear

    ReplyDelete
  34. Ai is far less relevant than milk

    ReplyDelete
  35. What the fuck is this clown talking about. He does know what milk is, correct?

    ReplyDelete
  36. Milk is regulated under RFK the lesser? Maybe they should pick a better analogy.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Is AI regulated at all? It might still be a valid analogy. After all, as undisciplined as they are they may have missed an existing milk regulation somewhere.

      Delete
    2. So what have we learned here ?

      GOP - let's remove the rest of the regulations on milk. Woohoo

      Delete

  37. These fucking chodes - we know.

    We’ve been saying this for literally years, when you were recoiling in horror at the very concept of regulation.

    We know you want it now because you already have an advantage, so hobbling any potential competition makes you the overall winner - or in microsoft’s case, they lost the race but have the capital and can catch up so long as they hobble any potential future threats now.

    The whole bubble is just capitalism 101, literally none of what any of these AI chodes say can be trusted or taken at face value. They will all lie for a higher investment pool, they will say literally anything.

    ReplyDelete
  38. 'We need regulatory capture now" -AI bros

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It's pretty easy to revenue gate legislation to target frontier labs.

      If we had legislated for social media in its infancy to advocate against customer harm do you think that would have been a good thing or a bad thing?

      Delete
  39. Asking for regulation as the open source models keep gaining traction... coincidence?

    ReplyDelete
  40. Organic grass-fed AI.

    ReplyDelete
  41. Opus is homogenized and pasteurized.

    ReplyDelete
  42. So, that means, what? We're going to deregulate milk now probably, right?

    ReplyDelete
  43. He’s making a good point

    ReplyDelete
  44. Don't worry, swill milk only had to kill 8,000 babies before the milk industry was regulated

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And I'm sure RFK Jr is working on getting rid of those, so soon "AI" can be just as regulated as milk

      Delete
    2. Ai will be used to create a super virus that exterminates 80% of humanity

      Delete
  45. Why is this a headline? Raw milk is dangerous.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's why milk is regulated. He's saying AI is like raw milk. We need to pasteurise AI.

      Delete
    2. Nuke it from orbit. It's the only way to be sure.

      Delete
    3. At least curtail free speech laws to prevent it from pointing out economic ineptitude.

      Delete
  46. So far I’d guess that cows are responsible for more human deaths than AIs have managed.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. If these assholes were so concerned about ai safety, they shouldn’t sell their shitty product, they should raise concerns about how ai is hurting people now instead of some doomsday scenario.

      Delete
  47. Die schreien und flehen alle nach Regulierung, weil ihr Geschäftsmodell von fähigen Entwicklern im OpenSource Bereich, sowie Modellen und lokalen Architekturen, gefährdet wird.

    Wenn die Blase deshalb platzt, verlieren sie und sehr viele Investoren so gut wie alles. Das ist mit Sicherheit auch der Grund warum einige schon ein hübsches Zimmer außerhalb des Landes planen.

    ReplyDelete
  48. Well yah I’ve never once even thought about giving my kid AI to ingest.

    ReplyDelete
  49. It was all fun and games when it was just "ai is gonna scrape all your data and then steal your jobs"

    Not so much fun once it becomes "ai is gonna let the proles reverse Engineer all your software"

    ReplyDelete
  50. yes, well stomach cancer used to be a leading cause of death until the FDA got involved.

    ReplyDelete
  51. Oh so now I understand the H1B issue.

    Bullying.

    ReplyDelete
  52. That’s not what he is saying, he saying that milk is innocuous but it’s regulated and ai is super dangerous and will wipe out humanity. The article is complete nonsense. Of course milk is regulated because if it wasn’t, you would die from poison. If he was so concerned about ai, why would he force co-pilot in windows, co-pilot is so dog shit.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Poor quality milk has killed 10's of thousands already.

      Delete
  53. AI is less regulated than milk RIGHT NOW.

    Junior's workin' on that...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah you will be allowed to drink milk straight from the cows teats soon

      And by cow I mean rat

      Delete
    2. Trump administration got the message. I guess now we have to deregulate milk!

      Delete
  54. AI is less regulated than a school's Canvas page.

    ReplyDelete
  55. Shhhh…. Damnit! There’s a good chance that these raw milk chugging lunatics will deregulate our milk!

    ReplyDelete
  56. Funny, someone just decided to copy MS word, excel and powerpoint and offer it for free with adobe rips.
    MS Office revenue is $111bn, or about 1/3 of the revenue the valuation of the company is built on.
    Whenever an exec opens their mouth, find out who has stopped to wipe their mouth.

    ReplyDelete
  57. Not in EU 🫠🇪🇺

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And Milk is pretty well regulated here

      Delete
    2. Somehow there are milk producers at EU

      Delete
  58. on the flip side. it is very important to regulate milk lotta people drink it

    ReplyDelete
  59. We are losing the AI war because our bet fucking sucks, better start calling for regulations.

    I’m not against it, but that is most likely what happened

    ReplyDelete
  60. Oh….wonder if they’ll dig into patent violations.

    ReplyDelete
  61. Considering all the recalls we’ve had that’s not the flex you think it is!

    ReplyDelete
  62. My nation’s federal government:

    “We should regulate this. Let’s write legislation.

    …

    Let’s abandon this legislation, see what happens, and potentially regulate as we go in response to lawsuits. People have to be harmed for that to happen, but it’s easier for us than trying to think of what might happen. Plus this way allows us to make more money, look good, and not say no to our corporate sponsors, I mean donors. Plus it’s not likely us that will be harmed, and if it is, we have money to deal with it”.

    ReplyDelete
  63. And to think the states want to sell their milk into Canadian markets, we can't have that can we?

    The local dairy here will have a fit.

    ReplyDelete
  64. Let's make you liable for all the job losses, how about that?

    ReplyDelete
  65. that’s essentially accurate.

    ReplyDelete
  66. AI does not need to be regulated.

    ReplyDelete
  67. what a weird comparison

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah.. something you ingest and can have deadly bacteria growing in it vs computer program. Very dumb thing to even compare

      Delete
    2. He’s not wrong though. Every single cocktail bar I worked at for the last 14 years had more regulation than this entire industry. The oligarchs are so in control of our government they just said “what if crime were legal?”

      Delete
    3. The AI oligarchy is calling for regulation to capture the market, make it impossible for anyone to compete making their investment to this point more valuable

      They came up with 0 regulation and now want it harder to get to that point. People need to stop mixing these up because it’s exactly what openAI and Anthropic both want, regulations

      Delete
    4. It can be both at the same time. They want regulations for themselves now for the purpose of regulatory capture but with zero repercussions for crimes they’ve already committed. If the new laws actually punished companies for illegal things they’d done in the past, they wouldn’t be pushing for them at all.

      Like stealing all their foundational data and paying pennies on the dollar years later or having misaligned models that make people kill themselves get the companies held liable for damages.

      Delete
  68. Someone give this child their glass of milk…

    ReplyDelete
Post a Comment
Previous Post Next Post