Given that officials have clarified that there are neither exclusive streaming rights or PC streaming, this article is a stain of what I call lazy, unverified reporting. And their updates to this article after being exposed as bs only made it more confusing
I'll just wait to play a pirated copy for free through a PS5 emulator on a gaming PC that I've yet to purchase. That way I won't have to pay for Xbox Cloud Gaming hours.
Actually I'll probably be enjoying Ocarina of Time instead
For real. Second paragraph alone should basically not be there anymore. They've already shot down the PC stuff, which is mentioned in the next paragraph, so why leave it there?
I'd assume this means a LARGE capital expenditure, especially on something that hasn't really caught on yet (game streaming). Every time I think I've got a handle on the Sharma regime, she throws me a curveball.
"While the excitement for GTAVI and XBOX is great to see, it has also led to some misreporting. We are looking forward to launching GTAVI on XBOX November 19, though the game will not be streaming exclusively or to PC." - Mathew Ball Posted 40 mins ago.
It’s worth remembering that Xbox Cloud Gaming is still available in only 29 countries. That leaves a huge part of the global gaming market without access despite many of those markets having perfectly capable broadband and mobile networks. Microsoft talks a lot about cloud gaming and “play anywhere,” yet it has been surprisingly slow to expand the service geographically. Meanwhile, playstation has spent decades building a genuinely global, localized presence across far more markets. With a game as globally significant as GTA VI, distribution matters. Microsoft may have secured a cloud-streaming advantage, but how much does that advantage really mean if most of the world can’t access it?
"Meanwhile, playstation has spent decades building a genuinely global, localized presence across far more markets."
Are you intentionally just hiding info to prop up Sony? PS+ game streaming is also only available in ~31 countries. In fact, PS+ cloud is mostly EU, US, and Japan. Xbox Cloud also covers South America, Australia, India, New Zealand, and pretty much far more of the globe by actual spread.
Ask the AI that phrased your comment for you for more info.
Fair point on PS+ streaming, but that’s not really what I’m arguing. PlayStation already has a massive global console presence. Xbox having streaming rights doesn’t mean much if the service isn’t available to most of the world. That’s my point. It just feels so desperate of them, like it’s a big win, but it’s not.
And as for AI, I’ll ask it to be more simpler so it’s easier to follow.
Xbox also has a massive global console presence. Xbox LIVE is even in more countries than PS+.
"And as for AI, I’ll ask it to be more simpler so it’s easier to follow."
I'll make my criticism simpler for you to follow: you can phrase your own opinion yourself instead of resorting to an LLM to fluff it with big words, forewords, backgrounds, etc.
You can just say "Xbox cloud streaming isn't available outside of X countries" instead of repeating it with "Microsoft talks a lot about X yet it has Y" and other "X and yet Y" or "X has done Y while Z has been doing A". You don't have to make it a one-paragraph smushed essay.
Long time ago, there was Barbara Krasnoff who would explain topics for beginners. I could really use one of these right now. 1. didn't cloud gaming suck? Especially for such a AAA one? 2. What happens when you run out of playing hours? This feels like the worst way to enjoy the monument this game will be. You can always count on Microsoft to ruin your life. Can we do a Microsoft takedown next?
Cloud gaming is terrible. I just tried Galactic Racer on Luna tonight. I have a high end PC and 2Gb service to my house. It was responsive as hell, but looked like it was barely 720p. 'm not playing anything for longer than 20 minutes like that.,
…Luna is hardly comparable to far more featured cloud gaming streaming services available today as Amazon has invested far less into the tech than most of the market
That's like dismissing ray-tracing and GPU-accelerated upscaling because AMD didn't invest nearly as much as Nvidia and Intel did with their GPUs (RDNA2 that current-gen consoles outside of the PS5 Pro have aged poorly with both things enabling a big jump when the baseline of consoles can move on from that very modest and half-hearted attempt to adopt current-gen tech).
Nvidia Geforce Now enables 5K@120hz w/ HDR for traditional computing devices and 4K@90hz consistently for spatial computing devices.
That's far better quality than the "720p" quality you speak of.
Luna is an outlier in being just "good enough" for Amazon to say they have cloud gaming, and it's also sort of on its last legs (no bring your own library anymore, games bought/claimed before were refunded recently, small rotating "party game" library). It's being reformatted into its own niche thing.
1) Cloud gaming is now very impressive on strong connections. Alas, Microsoft’s solution is a long way behind Nvidia’s. GeForce Now is leagues better than it used to be, BUT they won’t get GTA6 at least until it’s on PC.
2) When you run out of hours your session disconnects or you can buy more.
Yes, using streaming will usually be worse than native, especially Microsoft’s version, but it usually opens up new places to play and allows people without a gaming PC / console to enjoy games. But it sounds like this will only be console streaming, which is less versatile. However, GTA6 may well really struggle on Series S, so it remains to be seen if the Series X-powered stream will be a better experience.
I would want to see numbers for Cloud Gaming users who don’t own a Series X/S console. If I didn’t have a PlayStation I would rather wait for it to come on PC instead of playing it on the cloud. The game already looks so soft on base consoles that it’ll be like playing in half res + increased latency. I’m not gonna physically be able to handle playing it that way. That’s too much to give up for how much you have to pay for.
Cloud gaming is often a matter of convenience when you don't have access to consoles or a desktop like being on-the-road being able to play it via phone devices, laptops, and now spatial computing hardware plenty capable of playing the game via cloud streaming.
It's not far-fetched an increased amount of people see the appeal as people live busier lives than ever than be on a couch playing.
Even in modern work environments with game lounges, it not guaranteed at all others haven't secure the room to play other games (especially more local-multiplayer-oriented games like FIFA) or using the room for meetings as a last resort.
How is this bad? You still buy the game. You still own a digital copy of it. When/If you buy a physical Xbox, the game is waiting right there in your account. It's not part of the subscription like Netflix or Game Pass.
Because it's a slippery slope. We're already seeing the death of physical games. Streaming only games is the next step. I'm sure 2K/Rockstar would've made GTA6 a streaming only game if more people had the internet for it.
GeForce Now is nearly 15 years old. OnLive before it for a good few years. Xbox Cloud is from 2019. Whatever slippery slope you're imagining has existed for a long time and was carefully avoided by everyone.
"Whatever slippery slope you're imagining has existed for a long time and was carefully avoided by everyone."
Because we still have options! That might not be the case in five or ten years. Console and PC prices are sky high and it's extremely expensive for people to build a PC these days, and it doesn't look like it'll get any cheaper.
Do you not think that Microsoft and Nvidia would prefer that you pay them for a subscription each month instead of a one time payment for a game? Their wet dream is happening right now. Hardware is getting extremely expensive for most people, especially for the typical casual player who's not about to spend $3000 on a PC, or $1000 on a console. What do they do? They pay the damn $20-30 a month for streaming and play the game.
Microsoft and Nvidia wins. We, the consumers lose again.
That's the slippery slope that OP talks about.
You're thinking about today, while a lot of people are thinking about tomorrow.
No, I'm thinking about tomorrow too, but one is not caused by the other.
Of course Microsoft, Sony, Nvidia, etc. would prefer you to rent your hardware or stream your games, every one of those companies prefer services revenue. (With a tiny asterisk for Nvidia due to still wanting to sell some chips, but mostly yes for gaming)
And the current hardware price explosion due to AI driving up NAND and silicon allocations is certainly making streaming more palpable because of the cost difference, but that happening doesn't mean that now mean old Microsoft is going to shutter all owned hardware viability. They're not a comic book villain looking for an opening.
More people using streaming isn't what will make Microsoft shutter the physical console line, it's the cost of making them and component prices being driven up. So it's not a streaming slippery slope, it's a "it costs too much to make it" slippery slope, caused by NAND. When NAND pressure eases (new foundries or new manufacturers etc.) then the pressure drops, and even if some PC OEM pulled their product line, you'll have other PC competitors filling the void. (AMD/Intel, NVIDIA/AMD/Intel, Sony/Microsoft/"PC", etc.)
Look at what’s happened to the movie and series industry—everything is streamed now. The gaming industry has always been a few steps behind, so it might take a few more years to catch up.
For games not in the subscription? Yes. You're paying for hardware use in that case, just as you would pay for hours in a LAN cafe. (With the exception that a lot of games are included in the LAN cafe, but just like here, you have to bring a game license for anything they don't have/include)
the sub also offers a library of built-in streaming games (almost any game pass game can be streamed), but they *also* offer a feature where any (non-gamepass) game you've bought in the xbox/ms store can also be streamed (if you have an active subscription). The streaming ability is sort of like a bonus feature of the paid game, or a bonus gamepass feature to "add" any game to your game pass streaming library (by purchasing), depending on which way you want to look at it. I hope that made sense
So this is accurate: to stream GTA, you have to buy it for full price, then pay an additional subscription fee to stream it. And currently there are limits on how many hours a month you can stream, as well, as I understand it?
sort of. I don't believe the streaming limits have come into effect yet but I could be wrong about that. There were also some rumblings about existing game pass (maybe just ultimate tier?) subscribers being grandfathered into their old streaming arrangement, so no hour cap, at least for now, but I don't know what became of that. And there will also supposedly be a free ad-supported tier in the near future. But yes, the essence of your comment is basically correct for any outsider buying into gaming right now (if R* or Sony doesn't intervene and effectively bar the game from being streamed this way, which there are also rumors about).
Worth mentioning that the lowest tier of game pass has also replaced xbox live gold or whatever it was most recently called, so basically all online xbox players are some level of existing game pass subscriber too. But if you ever do buy an actual xbox it will be also be fully playable as if you just bought the game normally, and progress etc will also carry over, so it's not like paying for the full digital game on xbox to play on pc would restrict it to *only* the time-gated streaming service (this is *if* xbox does end up offering this feature for this game; I am basing it on my experience with other games and how they work across gamepass and cloud)
from here: https://news.xbox.com/en-us/2026/09/03/xbox-cloud-gaming-changes/
Game Pass Ultimate: 15 hours: ~$23 Game Pass Premium: 10 hours: ~$15 Game Pass Essential: 5 hours: ~$10
"Once subscribers use their included hours, they will be able to purchase additional cloud playtime through the XBOX Store. Available hours, purchasing options, and cloud gaming features may vary by market. We’ll share pricing and further details before the changes take effect... Players will be able to purchase cloud playtime hours through the XBOX Store and stream eligible games they own on supported devices."
Changes hit in November. I guess alot depends on how much those additional hours cost. I assume this will be at least a 60 hour game.
There's also a bundle of streaming hours without the Game Pass libraries, which should be cheaper for raw hours than GP+Game. And then you're essentially just renting hardware by the hour.
Yep. Like I said, will really depend on the cost per hour. If its like... $2 an hour, for a 60 hour+ game, plus you have to buy it for $70, that doesn't seem too economical to me vs just buying a used console then re-selling it when done.
If Xbox gets this as a streaming exclusive, and if it plays above the reported 30 FPS that the physical consoles are maxing at, people would flock to the platform to play it.
Game Pass Ultimate maxes at 15-hours a month, definitely forcing players to buy more hours a la carte (prices of which have not yet been announced). I don't think people are just going to play for 15-hours streaming and then play the rest on console.
Sounds like a scheme to print money. "The only way to play GTA 6 above 30 FPS" is one hell of a value prospect.
It won't be higher than what consoles can do as Xbox Cloud Gaming literally runs off hardware based on the Series X. The cloud can't magic extra frames in there
It's not the stupidest thing ever but it's not a great solution for PC players. You're literally limited to 15 hours per month in a game that most people will likely play for hundreds of hours. After those 15 hours you have to pay for additional streaming time and we don't even know what they're going to charge for that. For all we know it could end up being just as expensive and at that point you might as well have bought a new console anyway.
It sucks because they have the worst streaming service. GeForceNow and Luna are miles ahead in terms of streaming quality. Plus Microsoft added those ridiculous time limits.
If I’m interpreting correctly, this means no GTA VI on PS Plus Premium Streaming? That’s a bummer for Portal users, streaming performance has gotten really good recently. Ofc remote play remains an option but it is much more dependent on your network.
Then again, ever since folding PS Now into Plus, Sony hasn’t really tried to market PS Streaming to anyone who doesn’t already own a PlayStation console… who will just install the game anyway.
If they were to add Plus Cloud Streaming to the PS Remote Play app or a web player, then it’d really open up to new users.
I feel like cloud gaming is one of those markets that I keep getting told is about to go big for last ten years but it still feels practically as niche. It still feels like an accounting error in these companies’ bottom lines.
Yeah… it’s honestly super impressive and convenient at times but as someone who’s been watching the space since OnLive thinking it would go mainstream… it just became a bonus feature in Sony and Microsoft’s platforms, a side-hustle for NVIDIA and a way for AAA games to technically release on Switch 1.
It's pretty big nowadays, honestly. It's also been incredibly stable and works great for most games. And I feel it may just keep getting more mainstream because with the size of some of these games and the absurd cost of hard drive space it's just not very convenient sometimes to get games that require an install.
Seems like they were just trying to get ahead of a trend that isn't happening and are in too deep to quit. It's telling that some big players have also exited the market, like Amazon and Google after their failed attempts. Xbox, PS, and Nvidia have more gaming cred than Amazon and Google but I still don't think this bodes well for the whole concept.
…Just let the market play itself out. Hybrid compute gaming is only emerging being ultimately way too premature to think about cloud-only games accordingly.
Even if either arrives at large scale it'll be a good thing that there's more variety of games of any size being made that can completely alleviate physical hardware requirements rather than status quo today that long been needed of shake-ups for more variety of gaming experiences possible.
Both enables games of various fidelity and scale be more accessible to play at higher baselines than previously possible.
"I feel like cloud gaming is one of those markets that I keep getting told is about to go big for last ten years but it still feels practically as niche"
It reminds me of Duke Nukem Forever, flying cars and Linux on the desktop
The least wanted and least played version of the game is the one Microsoft just overpaid to secure as an exclusive.
This is like when Circuit City used to have the exclusive rights to Divx. Sure, you can watch movies on it, but why would you opt to watch them like that when you don't have to?
Because I'm not going to pay ~$1000 to play one single video game. Like your example, I'm not going to pay $1000 for a DVD player to watch one movie if I can pay $10 to watch the same movie, even if it's a little lower quality.
They pretty much just secured the exclusive rights to the "PC" version of the game, until an actual one is made
So it's more reasonable to pay $700 for a console and one game, than to pay ~$20 for a month of streaming?
Man, I guess the whole cost of living problem really was overblown if everyone thinks it's more reasonable to throw hundreds of dollars to play one game.
Where does it say it will be $20 a month? Unless you mean the limited version where you can play 20 minutes a day. It would take half a year to finish the game without doing side missions at that rate. $120 + Buying the game to play a bad version of the game over 6 months.
You still have to buy the game to stream it so you are paying $100 (or more, depends on what plan you have) in your example to play the game and you end up with nothing.
Also, all I was saying is their $1000 figure was way off.
But in general, I do think the cheapest way to play it (besides borrowing a console) would be to buy a used console and then sell it when you get bored of the game. You probably could sell the console for the same price you bought it for.
I do know this does seem a little bit like a nothing burger, but if Sony had any plans to push the PS Portal alongside the launch of GTA 6, then Microsoft may have ended up screwing over those plans.
I’m not so sure. For potentially millions of people, being able to access GTA VI without buying new hardware is huge, be them PC or Switch-only players and/or people who used to play these games when they were younger. Cloud gaming has gotten good enough assuming you have a reliable connection. Just the other day I drove around in GTA V/Online without reinstalling it. After a while I forgot it wasn’t local.
This could either be a genius move where people can play GTA VI on the TV or laptop they already own… or like you say nothing.
I would agree if only they didn't cap cloud streaming to 15 hours per month with additional hours behind a paywall. That's not enough for a game as large as GTA VI
i would love to know how much Microsoft is forking over for this deal, because it's almost certainly not cheap. there's no universe in which Rockstar is the one paying because this game is going to sell a billion copies no matter what, so this has to be a play by Xbox to try to cash in on the launch since it doesn't have very many consoles to sell the game on. interesting move, but we'll see if it pays off!
Seems as good a time as any to ask: Does cloud gaming actually work now? I tried it years and years ago and it was a mess. I have no idea if it's improved any in the time since or if it's still pretty bad
i have not tried it outside of wifi but it has worked great in my experience over the last couple years. i struggled to play Need for Speed Unbound because the frame rate couldn't keep up, but i've played a bunch of stuff this way when i didn't want to make space on my xbox and it was perfectly serviceable. i played all of Machine Games' Wolfenstein games (except Youngblood) that way and it was awesome. mostly played on console, but i've also played Fortnite on my iPad (before i realised it's available on the app store again) too and it was fine.
I have tried damn near every iterarion from OnLive to Xbox, PS Plus (formerly Now), etc. And honestly I’d say it has gotten good enough to sustain gaming sessions without frustration… assuming your connection is fast and stable.
I played some GTA V on PS Plus Cloud and totally forgot I was streaming it. Xbox should be on par if not better
Depends on what was your issue all those years ago.
I've had a very decent playable experience nearly 2 decades ago... and to make it sound even older, the client was a Java applet embedded in a web page.
Image quality has gotten tremendously better with both improved video encoding and much higher bitrate.
Latency has been reduced a lot, with both Internet infrastructure (FttH means very low latency to servers that are quite far away), and low-latency video encoders/decoder.
If there's a data center in your country (or region), it's pretty good. But there's a lot of if-s that still make it OK or good for niche cases, rather than the old dream of not needing to buy a console. (I still remember OnLive...)
My wife wanted to play Planet Zoo 2 that’s coming out next week and we didn’t want to have to buy her a whole PC the way things are (she’s mostly a Switch and Xbox player) so we tried Planet Zoo on GeForce Now and it’s been great. Now, would I play a competitive FPS? Probably not, but for something like GTA it’d be fine.
As an early Stadia user it was glorious. I played more games and finished campaigns than I had in the decade before. Latency was not an issue for a non competitive gamer like me, even with FPS shooters and racing games. No updates or futzing. As a casual gamer with a busy household life, I could pick up a device and start playing in 1-2 minutes usually. Almost as fast as resuming a book most times.
Played Cyberpunk (Stadia was the best Cyberpunk experience in the first two months of the game's botched buggy launch. PC, Consoles etc were far buggier during the launch window), Doom, Watch Dogs, Tom Clancy, RDR2 (100+ hours) at 4k60/4k30 usually.
Played on phone, wired computer, cast to my projector via Chromecast dongle, and iPad.
Stadia died due to a crappy business model. But man Google nailed the tech experience. GFN and xCloud took multiple years to match that performance (and GFN has now exceeded it with 120fps etc). Luna remained inferior.
I played Cyberpunk 2077 via GeForce Now back when it released. I've played a few Xbox Cloud games as well. For single-player, non-twitchy shooters, it works great. The most important thing is an Ethernet connection to your router for the best stability. Having high download speeds or fibre Internet means nothing if you're relying on your device's shitty WiFi chip with your likely super-crowded WiFi radio space.
My most "exotic" game session was playing Metaphor ReFantazio on my phone via Xbox Cloud during commutes. One of the few times Canada's shitty 5G rollout was actually beneficial. It absolutely hiccuped a few times depending on where I was on my trip, but it was super nice to get a bit of progress in on the go!
It absolutely works with Geforce Now that consolidates access to this service, Steam, and individual publisher's services such as EA's and Ubisoft's.
You can play at 5K@120hz with HDR on traditional computing or 4K@90hz consistently across spatial computing devices that a sight to behold on modern computing devices like high-end spatial computing headsets far above what they can natively run with their APUs.
It in particular adds much needed longevity to old handhelds like the Steam Deck OLED to play games at quality they never can run natively as well.
With quality internet it definitely has value as a luxurious means to play means that doesn't need to be necessarily a primary means someone plays games.
do you just shill for microsoft with fake news now? Tom Warren getting fact checked by IGN and others, and it's still up 2 days later.
ReplyDeletewhat are we paying for? cancelling my subscription now.
Hey blog moderators,
ReplyDeleteAre you going to ban my account if I say blog is fake news?
What a shame.
You have lost all trust.
Given that officials have clarified that there are neither exclusive streaming rights or PC streaming, this article is a stain of what I call lazy, unverified reporting. And their updates to this article after being exposed as bs only made it more confusing
ReplyDeleteClearly the entire article should be retracted. It's not even worth a story with the latest updates.
DeleteBut they don't have the balls to do that. So they modified the article to remove obviously incorrect content, which is just embarrassing.
I'll just wait to play a pirated copy for free through a PS5 emulator on a gaming PC that I've yet to purchase. That way I won't have to pay for Xbox Cloud Gaming hours.
ReplyDeleteActually I'll probably be enjoying Ocarina of Time instead
What’s the point of streaming it if you can only stream it to an Xbox… are they planning on dropping a streaming only xbox??
ReplyDeleteXbox One, last gen has cloud play genius
Delete13 year old console…
DeleteThis article is really confusing to read. It feels like it was partially redone after Matthew Ball called bs but not well enough.
ReplyDeleteFor real. Second paragraph alone should basically not be there anymore. They've already shot down the PC stuff, which is mentioned in the next paragraph, so why leave it there?
DeleteGlad it's not only me, what the hell is this article actually saying.
DeleteThe article should have been retracted.
Delete‘Stream GTA6 by the hour, exclusively on Xbox ?’ Irony is dead.
ReplyDeleteI'd assume this means a LARGE capital expenditure, especially on something that hasn't really caught on yet (game streaming). Every time I think I've got a handle on the Sharma regime, she throws me a curveball.
ReplyDeleteStreaming rights even being a thing for video games seems, at best, weird. So, that means all third-party streaming solutions are illegal?
ReplyDeletegaming paid for by the hour....wild
ReplyDeleteWhat does it mean that X-Box has the exclusive "streaming rights" to GTA? Does that mean I can't download and play it on PS5?
ReplyDeleteYou can play it. You just can't stream it, like you would a Netflix film.
DeleteYou've alluded to something important: nobody streams on PS5 anyway.
Microsoft just got burgled by Rockstar.
No, downloading is not streaming.
DeleteMatthew Ball debunked this.
ReplyDelete"While the excitement for GTAVI and XBOX is great to see, it has also led to some misreporting. We are looking forward to launching GTAVI on XBOX November 19, though the game will not be streaming exclusively or to PC." - Mathew Ball
ReplyDeletePosted 40 mins ago.
https://x.com/ballmatthew/status/2107667069797802443
B*stards.
DeleteBrutal takedown
DeleteThis blog has gone way downhill.
DeleteIt’s worth remembering that Xbox Cloud Gaming is still available in only 29 countries. That leaves a huge part of the global gaming market without access despite many of those markets having perfectly capable broadband and mobile networks. Microsoft talks a lot about cloud gaming and “play anywhere,” yet it has been surprisingly slow to expand the service geographically. Meanwhile, playstation has spent decades building a genuinely global, localized presence across far more markets. With a game as globally significant as GTA VI, distribution matters. Microsoft may have secured a cloud-streaming advantage, but how much does that advantage really mean if most of the world can’t access it?
ReplyDelete"Meanwhile, playstation has spent decades building a genuinely global, localized presence across far more markets."
DeleteAre you intentionally just hiding info to prop up Sony? PS+ game streaming is also only available in ~31 countries. In fact, PS+ cloud is mostly EU, US, and Japan. Xbox Cloud also covers South America, Australia, India, New Zealand, and pretty much far more of the globe by actual spread.
Ask the AI that phrased your comment for you for more info.
Fair point on PS+ streaming, but that’s not really what I’m arguing. PlayStation already has a massive global console presence. Xbox having streaming rights doesn’t mean much if the service isn’t available to most of the world. That’s my point. It just feels so desperate of them, like it’s a big win, but it’s not.
DeleteAnd as for AI, I’ll ask it to be more simpler so it’s easier to follow.
Xbox also has a massive global console presence. Xbox LIVE is even in more countries than PS+.
Delete"And as for AI, I’ll ask it to be more simpler so it’s easier to follow."
I'll make my criticism simpler for you to follow: you can phrase your own opinion yourself instead of resorting to an LLM to fluff it with big words, forewords, backgrounds, etc.
You can just say "Xbox cloud streaming isn't available outside of X countries" instead of repeating it with "Microsoft talks a lot about X yet it has Y" and other "X and yet Y" or "X has done Y while Z has been doing A". You don't have to make it a one-paragraph smushed essay.
Times have changed. Perhaps the blog could flag AI content in comments from now on.
DeleteLong time ago, there was Barbara Krasnoff who would explain topics for beginners. I could really use one of these right now.
ReplyDelete1. didn't cloud gaming suck? Especially for such a AAA one?
2. What happens when you run out of playing hours?
This feels like the worst way to enjoy the monument this game will be. You can always count on Microsoft to ruin your life. Can we do a Microsoft takedown next?
Cloud gaming is terrible. I just tried Galactic Racer on Luna tonight. I have a high end PC and 2Gb service to my house. It was responsive as hell, but looked like it was barely 720p. 'm not playing anything for longer than 20 minutes like that.,
Delete…Luna is hardly comparable to far more featured cloud gaming streaming services available today as Amazon has invested far less into the tech than most of the market
DeleteThat's like dismissing ray-tracing and GPU-accelerated upscaling because AMD didn't invest nearly as much as Nvidia and Intel did with their GPUs (RDNA2 that current-gen consoles outside of the PS5 Pro have aged poorly with both things enabling a big jump when the baseline of consoles can move on from that very modest and half-hearted attempt to adopt current-gen tech).
Nvidia Geforce Now enables 5K@120hz w/ HDR for traditional computing devices and 4K@90hz consistently for spatial computing devices.
That's far better quality than the "720p" quality you speak of.
Luna is an outlier in being just "good enough" for Amazon to say they have cloud gaming, and it's also sort of on its last legs (no bring your own library anymore, games bought/claimed before were refunded recently, small rotating "party game" library). It's being reformatted into its own niche thing.
DeleteAnd here I am loving cloud gaming and I use it nearly every day. There are many factors involved and simply saying it's 'terrible' is dishonest.
Delete1) Cloud gaming is now very impressive on strong connections. Alas, Microsoft’s solution is a long way behind Nvidia’s. GeForce Now is leagues better than it used to be, BUT they won’t get GTA6 at least until it’s on PC.
Delete2) When you run out of hours your session disconnects or you can buy more.
Yes, using streaming will usually be worse than native, especially Microsoft’s version, but it usually opens up new places to play and allows people without a gaming PC / console to enjoy games. But it sounds like this will only be console streaming, which is less versatile. However, GTA6 may well really struggle on Series S, so it remains to be seen if the Series X-powered stream will be a better experience.
This doesn't answer if it will be on Game Pass though (I assume not)
ReplyDeleteBrilliant I'll be first in line
ReplyDeleteNow that’s a business schmove right there
ReplyDeleteWonder how much money they paid for exclusivity so people could stream 20 minutes of GTA6 a day?
ReplyDeletehttps://x.com/ballmatthew/status/2107667069797802443?s=20
DeleteSo glad they’re doing this while laying off workers, good stuff Asha
ReplyDelete15 hours streaming with Ultimate 😂 With GTA that's a weekend 😂
ReplyDeleteI'm assuming that's just streaming and you could just download and install it like you can for other stuff on the service.
DeleteBut the article says streaming exclusivity, so if you can download it surely you have to own it?
DeleteYou can install anything on game pass last I checked. But I think this is like .. streaming only maybe. Idk it's very confusing
Delete"family of devices" God Xbox is so dead
ReplyDeleteAnd made by 3rd parties. Sounds like they are going the Windows route.
DeleteSounds like one of those things that a competitor pays for just to keep the other competitor from having it
ReplyDeleteI would want to see numbers for Cloud Gaming users who don’t own a Series X/S console. If I didn’t have a PlayStation I would rather wait for it to come on PC instead of playing it on the cloud. The game already looks so soft on base consoles that it’ll be like playing in half res + increased latency. I’m not gonna physically be able to handle playing it that way. That’s too much to give up for how much you have to pay for.
ReplyDeleteCloud gaming is often a matter of convenience when you don't have access to consoles or a desktop like being on-the-road being able to play it via phone devices, laptops, and now spatial computing hardware plenty capable of playing the game via cloud streaming.
DeleteIt's not far-fetched an increased amount of people see the appeal as people live busier lives than ever than be on a couch playing.
Even in modern work environments with game lounges, it not guaranteed at all others haven't secure the room to play other games (especially more local-multiplayer-oriented games like FIFA) or using the room for meetings as a last resort.
That makes sense I guess. I do use Moonlight every now and then to stream my games in bed but very rarely. But again, where are the numbers? Lol
DeleteWow, what a coup. /s
ReplyDeleteThe thought of streaming any game .. of not owning the hardware on which it runs .. just, no. Subscription services can't die soon enough.
ReplyDeleteHow is this bad? You still buy the game. You still own a digital copy of it. When/If you buy a physical Xbox, the game is waiting right there in your account. It's not part of the subscription like Netflix or Game Pass.
DeleteBecause it's a slippery slope. We're already seeing the death of physical games. Streaming only games is the next step. I'm sure 2K/Rockstar would've made GTA6 a streaming only game if more people had the internet for it.
DeleteGeForce Now is nearly 15 years old. OnLive before it for a good few years. Xbox Cloud is from 2019. Whatever slippery slope you're imagining has existed for a long time and was carefully avoided by everyone.
Delete"Whatever slippery slope you're imagining has existed for a long time and was carefully avoided by everyone."
DeleteBecause we still have options! That might not be the case in five or ten years. Console and PC prices are sky high and it's extremely expensive for people to build a PC these days, and it doesn't look like it'll get any cheaper.
Do you not think that Microsoft and Nvidia would prefer that you pay them for a subscription each month instead of a one time payment for a game? Their wet dream is happening right now. Hardware is getting extremely expensive for most people, especially for the typical casual player who's not about to spend $3000 on a PC, or $1000 on a console. What do they do? They pay the damn $20-30 a month for streaming and play the game.
Microsoft and Nvidia wins. We, the consumers lose again.
That's the slippery slope that OP talks about.
You're thinking about today, while a lot of people are thinking about tomorrow.
No, I'm thinking about tomorrow too, but one is not caused by the other.
DeleteOf course Microsoft, Sony, Nvidia, etc. would prefer you to rent your hardware or stream your games, every one of those companies prefer services revenue. (With a tiny asterisk for Nvidia due to still wanting to sell some chips, but mostly yes for gaming)
And the current hardware price explosion due to AI driving up NAND and silicon allocations is certainly making streaming more palpable because of the cost difference, but that happening doesn't mean that now mean old Microsoft is going to shutter all owned hardware viability. They're not a comic book villain looking for an opening.
More people using streaming isn't what will make Microsoft shutter the physical console line, it's the cost of making them and component prices being driven up. So it's not a streaming slippery slope, it's a "it costs too much to make it" slippery slope, caused by NAND. When NAND pressure eases (new foundries or new manufacturers etc.) then the pressure drops, and even if some PC OEM pulled their product line, you'll have other PC competitors filling the void. (AMD/Intel, NVIDIA/AMD/Intel, Sony/Microsoft/"PC", etc.)
Wait, is that really how it will work? You have to pay retail for the game, THEN ALSO, pay to stream it?
DeleteLook at what’s happened to the movie and series industry—everything is streamed now. The gaming industry has always been a few steps behind, so it might take a few more years to catch up.
DeleteWhat does this have to do with my question? Which was - do you have to pay retail price for the game to then also pay to stream it?
DeleteThere are games included in the subscription, and there are games out of that plan that you can purchase and play on the cloud.
DeleteIt's a flexible approach, that I personally like.
For games not in the subscription? Yes. You're paying for hardware use in that case, just as you would pay for hours in a LAN cafe. (With the exception that a lot of games are included in the LAN cafe, but just like here, you have to bring a game license for anything they don't have/include)
Deletethe sub also offers a library of built-in streaming games (almost any game pass game can be streamed), but they *also* offer a feature where any (non-gamepass) game you've bought in the xbox/ms store can also be streamed (if you have an active subscription). The streaming ability is sort of like a bonus feature of the paid game, or a bonus gamepass feature to "add" any game to your game pass streaming library (by purchasing), depending on which way you want to look at it. I hope that made sense
DeleteSo this is accurate: to stream GTA, you have to buy it for full price, then pay an additional subscription fee to stream it. And currently there are limits on how many hours a month you can stream, as well, as I understand it?
Deletesort of. I don't believe the streaming limits have come into effect yet but I could be wrong about that. There were also some rumblings about existing game pass (maybe just ultimate tier?) subscribers being grandfathered into their old streaming arrangement, so no hour cap, at least for now, but I don't know what became of that. And there will also supposedly be a free ad-supported tier in the near future. But yes, the essence of your comment is basically correct for any outsider buying into gaming right now (if R* or Sony doesn't intervene and effectively bar the game from being streamed this way, which there are also rumors about).
DeleteWorth mentioning that the lowest tier of game pass has also replaced xbox live gold or whatever it was most recently called, so basically all online xbox players are some level of existing game pass subscriber too. But if you ever do buy an actual xbox it will be also be fully playable as if you just bought the game normally, and progress etc will also carry over, so it's not like paying for the full digital game on xbox to play on pc would restrict it to *only* the time-gated streaming service (this is *if* xbox does end up offering this feature for this game; I am basing it on my experience with other games and how they work across gamepass and cloud)
from here: https://news.xbox.com/en-us/2026/09/03/xbox-cloud-gaming-changes/
DeleteGame Pass Ultimate: 15 hours: ~$23
Game Pass Premium: 10 hours: ~$15
Game Pass Essential: 5 hours: ~$10
"Once subscribers use their included hours, they will be able to purchase additional cloud playtime through the XBOX Store. Available hours, purchasing options, and cloud gaming features may vary by market. We’ll share pricing and further details before the changes take effect... Players will be able to purchase cloud playtime hours through the XBOX Store and stream eligible games they own on supported devices."
Changes hit in November. I guess alot depends on how much those additional hours cost. I assume this will be at least a 60 hour game.
There's also a bundle of streaming hours without the Game Pass libraries, which should be cheaper for raw hours than GP+Game. And then you're essentially just renting hardware by the hour.
DeleteYep. Like I said, will really depend on the cost per hour. If its like... $2 an hour, for a 60 hour+ game, plus you have to buy it for $70, that doesn't seem too economical to me vs just buying a used console then re-selling it when done.
DeleteIt's funny how many people think this is the stupidest thing ever, when this is the only way to play it on PC.
ReplyDeleteGuarantee lots of people are going to give it a shot if it means they can play the game without paying around $1000 for a console.
$1,000? You don't need to get a PS5 Pro.
DeleteOh you're right, $500 vs $20 is a much more reasonable argument.
DeleteLike really?
If Xbox gets this as a streaming exclusive, and if it plays above the reported 30 FPS that the physical consoles are maxing at, people would flock to the platform to play it.
DeleteGame Pass Ultimate maxes at 15-hours a month, definitely forcing players to buy more hours a la carte (prices of which have not yet been announced). I don't think people are just going to play for 15-hours streaming and then play the rest on console.
Sounds like a scheme to print money. "The only way to play GTA 6 above 30 FPS" is one hell of a value prospect.
It won't be higher than what consoles can do as Xbox Cloud Gaming literally runs off hardware based on the Series X. The cloud can't magic extra frames in there
DeleteAh, didn’t realize it was just Xbox X systems in a blade configuration. Thought it ran similar to Nvidia’s service.
DeleteMakes sense, Rockstar doesn’t have to optimize for another system configuration as it’s essentially another Xbox.
It's not the stupidest thing ever but it's not a great solution for PC players. You're literally limited to 15 hours per month in a game that most people will likely play for hundreds of hours. After those 15 hours you have to pay for additional streaming time and we don't even know what they're going to charge for that. For all we know it could end up being just as expensive and at that point you might as well have bought a new console anyway.
DeleteIt sucks because they have the worst streaming service. GeForceNow and Luna are miles ahead in terms of streaming quality. Plus Microsoft added those ridiculous time limits.
DeleteNaw just wait for the proper pc port, and don't ruin it with a 15fps 720p experience. There's a million others games to play in the meantime.
DeleteIf I’m interpreting correctly, this means no GTA VI on PS Plus Premium Streaming? That’s a bummer for Portal users, streaming performance has gotten really good recently. Ofc remote play remains an option but it is much more dependent on your network.
ReplyDeleteThen again, ever since folding PS Now into Plus, Sony hasn’t really tried to market PS Streaming to anyone who doesn’t already own a PlayStation console… who will just install the game anyway.
If they were to add Plus Cloud Streaming to the PS Remote Play app or a web player, then it’d really open up to new users.
Yea that's frustrating...but also I don't think I would've wanted to play a game like GTA vi on the portal. Need that big screen
DeleteI feel like cloud gaming is one of those markets that I keep getting told is about to go big for last ten years but it still feels practically as niche.
ReplyDeleteIt still feels like an accounting error in these companies’ bottom lines.
Yeah… it’s honestly super impressive and convenient at times but as someone who’s been watching the space since OnLive thinking it would go mainstream… it just became a bonus feature in Sony and Microsoft’s platforms, a side-hustle for NVIDIA and a way for AAA games to technically release on Switch 1.
DeleteTuga? 👀
DeleteHawk tuga?
DeleteNice 👌
DeleteIt's pretty big nowadays, honestly. It's also been incredibly stable and works great for most games. And I feel it may just keep getting more mainstream because with the size of some of these games and the absurd cost of hard drive space it's just not very convenient sometimes to get games that require an install.
ReplyDeleteIs it really that big? Lol
DeleteBig enough for Xbox, PS, and NVidia to offer it as a service and continuously add games that are capable of streaming rather than take away.
DeleteSeems like they were just trying to get ahead of a trend that isn't happening and are in too deep to quit. It's telling that some big players have also exited the market, like Amazon and Google after their failed attempts. Xbox, PS, and Nvidia have more gaming cred than Amazon and Google but I still don't think this bodes well for the whole concept.
DeleteThank God. I hope it stays niche. Publishers will start moving to cloud only games if the market is there.
Delete…Just let the market play itself out. Hybrid compute gaming is only emerging being ultimately way too premature to think about cloud-only games accordingly.
DeleteEven if either arrives at large scale it'll be a good thing that there's more variety of games of any size being made that can completely alleviate physical hardware requirements rather than status quo today that long been needed of shake-ups for more variety of gaming experiences possible.
Both enables games of various fidelity and scale be more accessible to play at higher baselines than previously possible.
"I feel like cloud gaming is one of those markets that I keep getting told is about to go big for last ten years but it still feels practically as niche"
DeleteIt reminds me of Duke Nukem Forever, flying cars and Linux on the desktop
The least wanted and least played version of the game is the one Microsoft just overpaid to secure as an exclusive.
ReplyDeleteThis is like when Circuit City used to have the exclusive rights to Divx. Sure, you can watch movies on it, but why would you opt to watch them like that when you don't have to?
Because I'm not going to pay ~$1000 to play one single video game. Like your example, I'm not going to pay $1000 for a DVD player to watch one movie if I can pay $10 to watch the same movie, even if it's a little lower quality.
DeleteThey pretty much just secured the exclusive rights to the "PC" version of the game, until an actual one is made
A ps5 is $599 new (you can find them for $350-400 used) so why would you need to pay $1000?
DeleteSo it's more reasonable to pay $700 for a console and one game, than to pay ~$20 for a month of streaming?
DeleteMan, I guess the whole cost of living problem really was overblown if everyone thinks it's more reasonable to throw hundreds of dollars to play one game.
Where does it say it will be $20 a month? Unless you mean the limited version where you can play 20 minutes a day. It would take half a year to finish the game without doing side missions at that rate. $120 + Buying the game to play a bad version of the game over 6 months.
DeleteYou still have to buy the game to stream it so you are paying $100 (or more, depends on what plan you have) in your example to play the game and you end up with nothing.
DeleteAlso, all I was saying is their $1000 figure was way off.
But in general, I do think the cheapest way to play it (besides borrowing a console) would be to buy a used console and then sell it when you get bored of the game. You probably could sell the console for the same price you bought it for.
DeleteI do know this does seem a little bit like a nothing burger, but if Sony had any plans to push the PS Portal alongside the launch of GTA 6, then Microsoft may have ended up screwing over those plans.
ReplyDeleteI've seen a good portion of people playing cloud nowadays... Seems like it's getting traction.
ReplyDeleteThat’s kind of nothing, guys.
ReplyDeleteI’m not so sure. For potentially millions of people, being able to access GTA VI without buying new hardware is huge, be them PC or Switch-only players and/or people who used to play these games when they were younger. Cloud gaming has gotten good enough assuming you have a reliable connection. Just the other day I drove around in GTA V/Online without reinstalling it. After a while I forgot it wasn’t local.
DeleteThis could either be a genius move where people can play GTA VI on the TV or laptop they already own… or like you say nothing.
I would agree if only they didn't cap cloud streaming to 15 hours per month with additional hours behind a paywall. That's not enough for a game as large as GTA VI
DeleteI love playing streaming games, particularly on my outside TV (or when traveling). I only do it for single player games.
Deletei would love to know how much Microsoft is forking over for this deal, because it's almost certainly not cheap. there's no universe in which Rockstar is the one paying because this game is going to sell a billion copies no matter what, so this has to be a play by Xbox to try to cash in on the launch since it doesn't have very many consoles to sell the game on. interesting move, but we'll see if it pays off!
ReplyDeleteSeems as good a time as any to ask: Does cloud gaming actually work now? I tried it years and years ago and it was a mess. I have no idea if it's improved any in the time since or if it's still pretty bad
ReplyDeletei have not tried it outside of wifi but it has worked great in my experience over the last couple years. i struggled to play Need for Speed Unbound because the frame rate couldn't keep up, but i've played a bunch of stuff this way when i didn't want to make space on my xbox and it was perfectly serviceable. i played all of Machine Games' Wolfenstein games (except Youngblood) that way and it was awesome. mostly played on console, but i've also played Fortnite on my iPad (before i realised it's available on the app store again) too and it was fine.
DeleteIt depends. Do you have a perfect Internet setup and happen to live close to one of the data centers?
DeleteDefine "close"? I've been doing cloud gaming with servers that were 3 countries away, and it was just fine.
DeleteWith optical fiber all the way from your home to the servers, you need to get pretty far away before the latency starts being problematic.
This is outdated at this point. Cloud gaming works fine with decent wi-fi nowadays.
DeleteI have tried damn near every iterarion from OnLive to Xbox, PS Plus (formerly Now), etc. And honestly I’d say it has gotten good enough to sustain gaming sessions without frustration… assuming your connection is fast and stable.
DeleteI played some GTA V on PS Plus Cloud and totally forgot I was streaming it. Xbox should be on par if not better
Yes it works. It still struggles with competitive multiplayer, but for single player, or to just try a game out on a lark, it’s GREAT.
DeleteDepends on what was your issue all those years ago.
DeleteI've had a very decent playable experience nearly 2 decades ago... and to make it sound even older, the client was a Java applet embedded in a web page.
Image quality has gotten tremendously better with both improved video encoding and much higher bitrate.
Latency has been reduced a lot, with both Internet infrastructure (FttH means very low latency to servers that are quite far away), and low-latency video encoders/decoder.
If there's a data center in your country (or region), it's pretty good. But there's a lot of if-s that still make it OK or good for niche cases, rather than the old dream of not needing to buy a console. (I still remember OnLive...)
DeleteMy wife wanted to play Planet Zoo 2 that’s coming out next week and we didn’t want to have to buy her a whole PC the way things are (she’s mostly a Switch and Xbox player) so we tried Planet Zoo on GeForce Now and it’s been great. Now, would I play a competitive FPS? Probably not, but for something like GTA it’d be fine.
DeleteAs an early Stadia user it was glorious. I played more games and finished campaigns than I had in the decade before. Latency was not an issue for a non competitive gamer like me, even with FPS shooters and racing games. No updates or futzing. As a casual gamer with a busy household life, I could pick up a device and start playing in 1-2 minutes usually. Almost as fast as resuming a book most times.
DeletePlayed Cyberpunk (Stadia was the best Cyberpunk experience in the first two months of the game's botched buggy launch. PC, Consoles etc were far buggier during the launch window), Doom, Watch Dogs, Tom Clancy, RDR2 (100+ hours) at 4k60/4k30 usually.
Played on phone, wired computer, cast to my projector via Chromecast dongle, and iPad.
Stadia died due to a crappy business model. But man Google nailed the tech experience. GFN and xCloud took multiple years to match that performance (and GFN has now exceeded it with 120fps etc). Luna remained inferior.
I played Cyberpunk 2077 via GeForce Now back when it released. I've played a few Xbox Cloud games as well. For single-player, non-twitchy shooters, it works great. The most important thing is an Ethernet connection to your router for the best stability. Having high download speeds or fibre Internet means nothing if you're relying on your device's shitty WiFi chip with your likely super-crowded WiFi radio space.
DeleteMy most "exotic" game session was playing Metaphor ReFantazio on my phone via Xbox Cloud during commutes. One of the few times Canada's shitty 5G rollout was actually beneficial. It absolutely hiccuped a few times depending on where I was on my trip, but it was super nice to get a bit of progress in on the go!
I remember slower paced games working OK, while Forza Horizon and other faster paced games being a mess and basically unplayable.
DeleteIt absolutely works with Geforce Now that consolidates access to this service, Steam, and individual publisher's services such as EA's and Ubisoft's.
DeleteYou can play at 5K@120hz with HDR on traditional computing or 4K@90hz consistently across spatial computing devices that a sight to behold on modern computing devices like high-end spatial computing headsets far above what they can natively run with their APUs.
It in particular adds much needed longevity to old handhelds like the Steam Deck OLED to play games at quality they never can run natively as well.
With quality internet it definitely has value as a luxurious means to play means that doesn't need to be necessarily a primary means someone plays games.